BGT 2024-25: Alex Carey defends third umpire amid controversy over Jaiswal's dismissal in boxing day test
Xtra Time Web Desk: Australia’s wicketkeeper-batter Alex Carey has raised concerns over the accuracy of the snickometer technology following the controversial dismissal of India’s Yashasvi Jaiswal during the Boxing Day Test in Melbourne. Carey’s remarks came during a press conference ahead of the New Year’s Test in Sydney, where he backed the third umpire’s decision while questioning the consistency of the ultra-edge technology used in the series.
Sharing his thoughts on the incident, Carey said, "I had no doubt and I think that the evidence was really clear that the third umpire made the right decision. Snico has been a little bit funny in this series. I think it is about taking a decision with all the evidence that you get and come up with a decision. I think the third umpire did a really good job."
Read More:
BGT 2024-25: Michael Clarke backs Nitish Kumar Reddy for No. 6 role in Sydney test against Australia
The controversy unfolded on Day 5 of the fourth Test, when Jaiswal, batting on 94, was adjudged caught behind by the third umpire despite the snickometer showing no visible spike as the ball passed his glove. The decision sparked debates as Jaiswal was India’s last recognized batter, fighting to salvage the match.
The incident occurred in the 71st over when Jaiswal mistimed a pull shot, resulting in the ball deflecting toward Carey behind the stumps. Carey took the catch and appealed, but on-field umpire Joel Wilson remained unconvinced and declared Jaiswal not out.
Read More:
BGT 2024-25: Will SCG have a flat pitch too? Curator weighs in
Australian captain Pat Cummins opted for a DRS review, leading to a prolonged evaluation. Although the ultra-edge displayed no spike, third umpire Sharfuddoula Saikat overturned the on-field call, relying on visual evidence of the ball’s deflection.
While the Australians celebrated the breakthrough, Jaiswal appeared visibly shocked by the decision. The controversial call added to the drama of the match, leaving cricketing experts and fans divided over the use of technology in such tight situations.
As India prepares for the final Test in Sydney, the fallout from Jaiswal’s dismissal continues to spark discussions about the reliability of DRS and its impact on critical match moments.
