MCC not in favour of Tendulkar”s suggestion of two pitches
Internet Desk: In order to bring about a balance between bat and ball, the game’s lawmakers – Marylebone Cricket Club (MCC) – has recommended limiting bat size edges and depths.
In addition, the MCC’s World Cricket Committee, headed by former England captain Mike Brearley that met here for two days ending today, has also come up with the radical suggestion of introducing a football-hockey-like red card as punishment for violent acts on the cricket field.
The committee also deliberated on the ball-tampering laws which it felt will remain unaltered, was split vertically on the possibility of reducing Test cricket from a five-day affair to a four-day one, it was announced by Brearley, former Australian captain Ricky Ponting, former Pakistan opener Rameez Raja and MCC’s head of cricket – John Stephenson – on Wednesday.
Other recommendations included urging the International Cricket Council, the world body governing the game, to continue to work towards introducing a World Test Championship and presenting the case for cricket at the Olympic Games and changing the law on ball striking a fielder’s helmet, it was announced by the panel.
All these recommendations will be sent to the main MCC Committee and if approved these changes will be implemented into the new code of the Laws of Cricket, which will be introduced on October 1, 2017.
On the suggestion to reduce the bat size, Ponting said that 60 per cent of the world’s professional players supported the decision to limit them to 40 mm on edges and 67 mm for depths, including 7 mm for curvature.
“We want to limit the edges to 38-42 mm. Some of the players have edges in excess of 50mm. We are happy with what we have come up which will restore the balance between the bat and the ball. We have seen top-edges and leading edges going for sixes. Even with the limit in bat size big hitters can still clear the ropes,” said Ponting.
It was announced that the ball tampering law, which was recently in the news when South Africa captain Faf du Plessis was caught on camera using a mouth mint to polish the ball during the series in Australia, will remain the same.
“Don’t be caught,” was the advice given by both Brearley and Raja.
On the question of the player being red carded Brearley said it will act as a deterrent.
“We discussed the yellow card (temporary) suspension too but then decided against it. The red card is for most extreme cases only,” the former England opener said.
As per the suggestion, umpires will be given the power to eject cricketers from a game for serious disciplinary breaches.
The player can be removed for threatening an umpire, physically assaulting another player, umpire, official or spectator or for any other act of violence on the field of play.
The reason for this radical suggestion was that cricket is one sport in which there is no in-match punishment for poor behaviour of the player by the umpires, the committee felt.
The change in the law striking a fielder’s helmet says that catches and stumpings will be permitted after the ball has struck a fielder’s worn helmet. At present catches and stumpings may be taken off a wicket keeper’s pads, the use of which is optional, and so it seems unfair that they should not be permitted after hitting a helmet, the wearing of which has become compulsory in the game in some countries, the committee said.
The change for the caught law will include a ball becoming lodged or trapped in the grille of the fielder’s helmet, in the same way as it is caught if it gets trapped between the wicket keeper’s pads or in a fielder’s sweater or pocket, the committee stated.
The committee also discussed four-day Tests and day-night Tests and was split on the former suggestion.
The radical suggestion of cricket icon Sachin Tendulkar to use two pitches in Ranji Trophy matches to enable Indian players get used to differing playing surfaces has not found favour with the MCC’s World Cricket Committee which felt it devalued the game.
“First class cricket is about playing competitive (cricket), challenging yourself. It (playing on two pitches) will be like lessening the importance of first class cricket.
That is what the committee felt,” said Marylebone Cricket Club’s World Cricket Committee member and former Pakistan captain Rameez Raja at a media conference after the panel’s two-day meeting here.
Committee chairman and former England skipper Mike Brearley echoed the same view.
“We talked about that too. We talked about the conflict between using first-class matches as training and the fact that they are proper games of cricket in a proper competition, proper feeling that you’re in a real match. Those two things can be in conflict,” said Brearley.
“I personally think the committee would have probably said the same, that we felt that (the idea of Tendulkar) went too far in turning first class cricket into mere practice matches for international cricket,” he added.
Both Raja and Brearley were reacting to the idea put forth by Tendulkar at a recent event in New Delhi.
Tendulkar had suggested that every Ranji Trophy game should be played on two different pitches to prepare a better Test team for overseas assignments.
He also wanted two balls (a kookaburra and a SG ball) to be used in two innings of a match which he reasoned would take a curator preparing designer pitches out of the equation and also would nullify the toss factor.
“Let us have the first innings on a green top with kookaburra balls which would give openers a challenge. Even bowlers will have something. Our spinners will also learn how to bowl with kookaburra on green tops,” Tendulkar had said.
“Now let there be a pitch adjacent to the green top which would be a rank turner. Now the second innings will be played on that track with the SG Test ball which would also help our batsmen play against quality spin bowling,” he had said.
About the need to try and include cricket in the Olympic Games, the committee said that the Indian Cricket Board chief Anurag Thakur, who was asked about it separately, told them that he had “an open mind” on the subject.
BCCI has been a stumbling block in the past over cricket being played in multi-sport Games such as Olympics, Asian Games and Commonwealth Games. The next meeting of the committee will be held at Lord’s London on July 3 and 4.